Monsters on Mondays | Chapter 4: The Critic

This entry is part 6 of 15 in the series Monsters on Mondays

In which the author describes how she came to be a critic and her life as a critic:

“…I somehow never was able to transcend the sense that I was an audience member, rather than a professional.” p. 198

I struggle with imposter syndrome. Our author, Dederer, was a professional critic when she was very young, by virtue of being hired by a small indy paper. (paid = professional) There was a time that I thought I would be a writer, but what I’ve grown to believe is that I’ve always been a critic. Or rather, a critic minus an audience. I’m 100% positive my friends are over my long-winded expositions on various films. I’m also 100% positive they are completely unimpressed by my film choices. 

A couple of years ago I was finally moved enough by a film to put my thoughts out into the world. (See: Cinema | NYCNorma) Since then, I’ve entertained myself by writing about any film I damn well please. No one is paying me, so I can watch what I want and say what I want. Still, I want to be good at things and that includes critique, so I found this chapter very interesting. 

The author’s structure for reviewing: 

  1. What is the film trying to do? 
  2. Does it succeed? 
  3. Was it a worthy objective in the first place?

These are actually hard questions. When I apply these to film, I’m immediately catapulted back through time to my literary criticism class in university. I really struggled with that class. My long-suffering professor Dr. Park frequently left notes on my papers that said things like “I want to know what you think.” That was what I thought, lady! It was hard to defend myself because then I would have to confess that I hadn’t done any of the reading. <slinks away> 

So what role do critics play for me? Honestly, not much. 

I don’t read reviews. This isn’t a hill I’m trying to die on; I just don’t like that I might be subjected to spoilers. And because I don’t read reviews, I’m not familiar with the herd of film critics out there. I have no doubt that somewhere there is a critic I would learn to trust. To the point of the author, that person is probably a woman. For a while, I subscribed to a newsletter called Cherry Picks. It aggregates and hosts reviews from people who are female and non-binary. I like the idea of it, but you know, the spoiler fear. I sometimes password-protect my posts that contain spoilers–because spoilers. I don’t want to be responsible for that. I’m also torn between my own desire to be a critic and to reject “criticism.” Am I even qualified to be a critic? Do I have to be hired and paid by someone else to be a critic? Who decides? 

Back to the literary criticism class… 

I was required to take literary criticism as a pre-requisite for all other upper level courses. I get why it was required, but also I found it pretty dumb. Even though dear Dr. Park said she wanted to know what I thought, she obviously didn’t believe me. In other words, she didn’t recognize mine as a voice of authority. (What was I saying about imposter syndrome?) And a lot of what we discussed in class anyway was meanings of things that someone else had decided long before I enrolled. Please tell me why, every time I read about a woman on horseback, the symbolism is phallic? I grew up riding horses. I can assure you it’s not. Anyway, I decided it was all pointless and now I’m afraid that by rejecting these decided-upon conclusions, I have no qualifications.

Our author found that her voice was also suspect: she approached her work in a different way than other Seattle critics (men) and that way largely boiled down to how she felt about film. She kept slipping into the role of audience, which felt frowned upon. She, too, struggled with having an authoritative voice; she, too, looked for theories of critique. That’s how she fell back on the three questions up there. ^ 

Eventually she seems to have landed where I’ve landed, which is in a subjective space in which I can say I feel something, I experienced something, I think something, and now I see myself reflected in something.  The male critic may struggle to conceive that there are valid viewpoints that aren’t HIS: white male subjectivity remains invisible. But white male experiences obviously aren’t the only ones. Considering demographics, one could argue that white male experiences are far from being the most common. 

“Aesthetic experience is tied to nostalgia and memory -that is to say, to subjective experience. Lived experience expands and illuminates the art we take in.” p. 290

Lived experience makes art accessible, available, understandable, relatable. It can’t be decoupled. So that’s why so many of us are crying out to see ourselves represented in all the arts–and in the critique as well. We want to be part of the conversation and that doesn’t seem like a big ask. Dederer astutely points out here that the white male critic can’t see he’s part of a group because he’s never been left out. Meanwhile, there are many of us who have experienced sexual violence at the hands of men and we will look at the art of monsters differently because of it. We have been molested, harassed, assaulted in public and private, raped, stalked, leered at. Almost all of us. 

“This tension–between what I’ve been through as a woman and the fact that I want to experience the freedom and beauty and grandeur and strangeness of great art–this is at the heart of the matter. It’s not a philosophical query; it’s an emotional one.” p. 197

So here we are, the author and I and maybe you, accusers, who still want the chance to experience and admire art. Is it fair to be denied that? Is it fair to be judged by anyone else if we want it? If we, the viewer, are bringing our subjective feelings, experience, and critique to the art, who can stop us? 

For further reading: The American Cinema by Andrew Sarris

Monsters on Mondays

Monsters on Mondays | Chapter 3: The Fan Monsters on Mondays | Chapter 5: The Genius

Your post must include a link to this post.

How does this work?
Write a response on your own website and include a link to this post. Then submit your response’s URL here. Your response may appear here after moderation. To update or remove it, edit or delete your original post and submit the same URL again. Learn more about Webmentions.