[Written after reading MAYPOCALYPSE! by Richard Rushfield and listening to a riveting premium episode of Pantsuit Politics.]
If there’s one thing I have thoughts about, it’s cinema.
I bemoan regularly the lack of imagination in the world around me–and I’m super lucky because I work at a school that revolves around creativity (where just last week I yelled that no one had an imagination) and I live in an epicenter of creativity. I also bemoan the incessant remakes and reboots and prequel/sequels. So I believe what we have in Hollywood (NOT the film industry as a whole) is a lack of imagination and a real aversion to risk-taking. Some of it does have to do with making a profit. But look: if you’re going to spend $250 million on a superhero movie, you have to make at least that much back to break even. If you have an opening box office number of $50 million, yikes. But who asked you to spend that much on one movie?
[Interrupting myself here to say that I KNOW three of the top ten box office “hits” of 2023 were megasuperhero movies. Don’t @ me.]
Something that was interesting about the SAG-AFTRA strike were the calls for “stars” to ask their agents to look at productions being mounted by indie companies. Forgive my naivety, but I thought agents have always been busy looking across all available job offerings. Guess not. The indies were like “Look at us! We are meeting your demands already.” That’s why we saw waivers being handed out to the likes of A24.
The stories being told by independent production companies are fantastic–far superior to those of the big five, in my opinion–but then we get into the problem of distribution. The beginning of 2022 found me in a right state trying to see Women Talking when the vast majority of screens and showtimes were taken up by Avatar. In New York City, Avatar was given dozens of showings a day across all theaters. I ended up having to take time off work to see Women Talking, which was given one showing per day (at 10:30 am) at the AMC theater most convenient to my office. Which came first: the box office bonanza or the takeover of entire theaters for weeks?
Some of the festival films with the best reviews AND positive audience chatter have trouble striking distribution deals in the U.S. I’m still waiting on a few from before COVID. And some get deals that send them straight to streaming. It’s not quite the equivalent of direct-to-DVD, but there is some luster lost when you skip an actual movie theater. Meanwhile, even in a place like NYC or LA, with so many dedicated cinephiles, theaters are languishing. I don’t blame COVID; I’m going to take this whole thing back to the computer that sits comfortably in my hand or pocket or bag.
I liken the inability to imagine to the loss of wonder. Why sit around and wonder when you can whip out your phone and do a quick search? Why go to a movie theater when you can whip out your phone and watch the tiny screen? It’s the same, according to some people I know. They’re completely wrong, but they insist it’s so. Going to the cinema is a singular communal experience. I love it when directors tell us how we are meant to view their films. Christopher Nolan’s Oppenheimer was shot on large format film stock, a combination of IMAX 65mm and Panavision 65mm, and he said to see the film in an IMAX theater that can accommodate 70mm. So off I went to do that. Me and several hundred others had that experience together and it was worth the slight location hassle and the wait it took to get a ticket. I don’t know if I’ve ever regretted seeing a film in a theater; even if the film was mediocre, we were all groaning together. But there’s magic in the darkness, when the lights go down and the sound goes up, the immersion in a story that is not yours, but kind of is, brought to larger-than-life proportions. It’s thrilling when everyone laughs at a subtle shift onscreen and you were just about to wonder if you were the only one who got it. It’s affirming when tears stream down your cheeks and you hear someone sob from the row over. Catharsis on a grand scale. Group therapy. In it together when the bomb drops and the plot thickens.
And finally, use it or lose it. There is only one movie theater in the Bronx right now because the other remaining theater just closed. While reading about it, there were so many people so sad about the closure who also admitted it had been a long time, sometimes years, since they’d bought a ticket. Well, what do you expect?

